Am 9 To Pm 9 Survival Penliner (0.6g)

"The color payoff is amazing and the staying power is incredible. I only use this eyeliner. I'm using it by sharpening it to be thinner, but I wish the pen itself was slimmer. Still, I'm satisfied with it!"

— Arvilla (4/5)

"This brush pen eyeliner might be a bit challenging for beginners to use, but the pigmentation is really impressive. I did my makeup at 9 AM, spent the whole day out, and returned to my accommodation at 9 PM, and it barely smudged, showing great staying power. It's perfect for creating sharp winged lines because of its vivid color, but not ideal for filling in the waterline, so I use eyeshadow for that and reserve this liner for the wings. I'm currently on my second one, and each lasts about 6-7 months. I’ll probably buy another once this one runs out. I'm really satisfied with this eyeliner."

— Tilda (5/5)

"This is my go-to product that I keep repurchasing! It's relatively affordable, doesn't smudge, and applies well, making it a reliable choice for regular use. 🤍"

— Chrystal (5/5)

"I've been a loyal user of the Lilybyred pen liner for years, and recently repurchased the 'Matte Brown' shade for my natural makeup look these days!"

— Christabel (5/5)

"I bought this because I ran out of eyeliner, and I'm really enjoying it. I'm thinking of trying other colors too."

— Mélina (5/5)

"Even with my clumsy hands, I can effortlessly draw with this eyeliner. With other products, using black-brown or black eyeliners made my expression look too harsh, and I often ended up applying too much on the waterline. But this one is easy to apply without any worries. It doesn't smudge unless you rub it really hard, so I'll definitely repurchase once I run out!"

— Amber L. (5/5)

"This is my first time using the Lilbare liner, and I'm really enjoying it. It applies smoothly and easily."

— Tomeka (5/5)

"The walnut brown color looks really natural. If you want something more natural than black, go for this one."

— Concha (5/5)

"I have monolids with a snowy look, so I need to fill in the waterline. When I apply it there, it smudges as soon as I close my eyes, so I have to let it dry quickly. It makes my eyes sting quite a bit, maybe because it gets into my eyes. I'll probably use it lightly just for the wing. If you don't like bold eyeliners, I recommend this one! The wing part stayed intact for 8 hours, probably because there's not much friction there!"

— Brooke M. (5/5)

"If bold eyeliner doesn't suit you, I highly recommend this one. It looks naturally beautiful and I'm really satisfied with it."

— Mia L. (5/5)