Starry Eyes Am 9 To Pm 9 Gel Eyeliner (0.5g)

"This is exactly the deep dark brown color I was looking for. I also bought two other colors, and I love them all! I use the brown shade to draw my eyeliner, and it glides on so smoothly, which I absolutely love! It hardly smudges and lasts a really long time!"

— Racheal (4/5)

"My sister tried the mini size of the sheer pink that she got as a freebie somewhere and loved it so much that she asked me to buy it for her. She says it's perfect for her under-eye area."

— Joycelyn (5/5)

"The color is beautiful, kind of like a rose pink. . . ? 🤍 It gives your eyes a more defined look when applied to the under-eye area. I usually use Daiso products, and the color is almost identical to theirs! However, this one applies more smoothly and the color is a bit prettier. . . 🤍 I think it will be perfect for drawing underlines! hehe"

— Teela (5/5)

"Adding a touch of sparkle under the eyes makes them look so pretty! The shimmer is subtle and not overdone, which is perfect. You can layer it for more shine, and it stays put without smudging or fallout. It's quite resistant to regular cleansers, so you'll need a lip and eye remover followed by cleansing oil to take it off. I also have the Golden Pink, but I find the Shine Gold even more beautiful, so I'm sticking with this one!"

— Tawana (5/5)

"I bought this after seeing it on YouTube, where the under-eye triangle color looked really pretty. It looks just as nice in person as it did on screen. I'm looking forward to using it. Unlike the thin pencils that are common in new products these days, this one is a bit thicker, making it easier to fill in the triangle zone."

— Luna S. (5/5)

"I bought all three colors and I love them all! Especially the Mellow Coral, which has a hint of coral with a touch of brown. It gives my eyes a deep, sophisticated look when I apply it under my eyes. I'm really pleased with it."

— Tatia (5/5)

"Just remember this one thing! Cleansing tissues, cleansing water, and cleansing foam won't remove it completely 🤣 I had to scrub it off my hand with cleansing oil, and even then, it was a struggle. My hand turned red, but that's a secret! 😂 Once applied, it sticks to your skin like glue and won't budge. I tend to sweat a lot, so my eye makeup usually smudges in hot weather, but not anymore! As the weather warms up, I'm feeling confident thanks to the Lilybyred eyeliner 😆"

— Maëva (5/5)

"The Lilybyred Slim Gel Eyeliner is so easy to apply! I've been using pencil liners since I was young, and I love how quick and effortless it is to use."

— Trudy (5/5)

"This is my go-to liner, so I decided to try it in other colors. While it's not completely smudge-proof, I love how easy it is to apply and draw with."

— Anvi (5/5)

"Initially, I was planning to buy several items, but I decided to just get the one that caught my eye the most, fearing I might regret it if they didn't suit me. Now, I'm regretting not buying more. . . It's so good that I wish I had bought several! It applies incredibly smoothly, leaves no residue, and the fixing power is amazing—once applied, it doesn't smudge at all! I even attached a photo of it on the back of my hand, and when I tried to wipe it off with a wet tissue, it wouldn't come off, so I had to scrub it with a cleansing wipe. Why did I only discover this now? The color payoff is beyond my expectations. I applied it to the inner corners of my eyes and my lower lash line, and it sparkles beautifully! The staying power exceeds what I anticipated, leaving me speechless. From now on, my eyeliner choice is definitely Lilybyred!"

— Heidi S. (5/5)